TLDR
Indiana does not impose a blanket reserve study mandate, but volunteer board members still owe fiduciary duties under IC 32-25.5 and IC 32-25. Boards that fail to plan for capital expenditures can be held personally liable for negligence even without a specific statutory reserve requirement.
Indiana’s absence of an explicit reserve study mandate sometimes creates a false sense of security for volunteer boards. IC 32-25.5 and IC 32-25 do not prescribe how to fund reserves, but they impose fiduciary duties with real consequences in litigation. When an Indiana HOA board allows common elements to deteriorate because reserves were never set aside and unit owners face a large special assessment, a court asks whether the board acted in the best interest of the association. The answer depends on whether the board had a documented plan.
Indianapolis is the dominant HOA market in Indiana, with substantial planned community development in Hamilton, Hendricks, and Johnson counties. These communities often have extensive amenity packages, pools, clubhouses, trails, that represent significant future capital expenditures. South Bend’s condo market, driven partly by proximity to the University of Notre Dame, adds complexity because condo associations face both private CC&R reserve requirements and the general fiduciary standard of IC 32-25.
BoardStack was built for boards in states like Indiana, where the law provides no compliance checklist but holds boards to a standard of care. The platform enforces account separation at the software level so reserves are never commingled with operating funds, and it gives boards a clear record of capital planning decisions that serves as evidence of good-faith fiduciary conduct.
No Blanket Reserve Study Mandate
Indiana's Homeowners Association Act (IC 32-25.5) and the Indiana Condominium Act (IC 32-25) do not require associations to conduct formal reserve studies. However, this does not eliminate the fiduciary obligation, boards must still act in the best interest of the association, which courts have interpreted to include planning for foreseeable capital expenditures.
Fiduciary Duty Under IC 32-25.5-3-2
IC 32-25.5-3-2 requires HOA board members to act in good faith and in the best interest of the association. Failure to maintain adequate reserves, resulting in a sudden special assessment or deterioration of common elements, can constitute a breach of this fiduciary duty, exposing board members to personal liability even though no reserve study statute exists.
Annual Meeting and Budget Requirements (IC 32-25.5-2-3)
Indiana HOA boards must hold annual meetings and present a budget to members. While the statute does not specify reserve line items, governing documents often require them. Boards should review their CC&Rs and bylaws, as many Indiana associations have private reserve requirements embedded in their declarations.
Fannie Mae Reserve Allocation Requirement
Fannie Mae Lender Letter LL-2026-03 sets two deadlines: (1) The Limited Review process for condo projects is retired effective August 3, 2026. (2) The minimum reserve allocation increases from 10% to 15% for Full Review loan applications dated on or after January 4, 2027. Associations below the 15% threshold will be classified as non-warrantable, preventing conventional mortgage lending on units in the community.
Good-Faith Planning Reduces Liability
Indiana courts apply the business judgment rule to HOA board decisions. Boards that document capital planning decisions, even informally, are in a stronger position than boards that never address long-term maintenance. Engaging a reserve specialist, even voluntarily, creates a defensible record.
| Metro Area | Estimated HOA Communities | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Indianapolis Metro | ~5,000+ | Largest market; strong suburban planned community growth in Hamilton and Hendricks counties |
| Fort Wayne | ~900+ | Growing second market; mix of condo and townhome associations |
| South Bend / Mishawaka | ~600+ | University-adjacent condo market; Notre Dame area drives condo demand |
| Evansville | ~400+ | Southwest Indiana regional market; older condo stock |
Q&A
What does Indiana law require for HOA reserve funds?
Indiana's HOA Act (IC 32-25.5) and Condominium Act (IC 32-25) do not mandate reserve studies or specific reserve funding levels. However, board members owe fiduciary duties under IC 32-25.5-3-2 that require planning for the association's long-term financial health. Many Indiana associations also have reserve requirements written into their CC&Rs or declarations that are independently enforceable.
Q&A
How can Indiana HOA boards protect themselves from personal liability?
Indiana boards are best protected by documenting their capital planning decisions, having their governing documents reviewed for reserve requirements, and voluntarily commissioning reserve studies that give the board a documented basis for funding decisions. The business judgment rule protects boards that act in good faith with reasonable information, not boards that simply ignore long-term capital needs.
Q&A
What is the Fannie Mae reserve allocation requirement for Indiana associations?
Fannie Mae requires associations to allocate at least 10% of their annual budget to reserves. Fannie Mae Lender Letter LL-2026-03 sets two deadlines: the Limited Review process is retired effective August 3, 2026, and the minimum reserve allocation increases to 15% for Full Review loan applications dated on or after January 4, 2027. Non-warrantable classification which freezes conventional mortgage lending on units in the community. This applies to all Indiana associations regardless of state law.
Ready to try BoardStack?
Pick a plan to see pricing details and next steps. Start a 1-month free trial with a card, and we will email you 3 days before it ends.
See plans & pricingReady to get your Indiana HOA board compliant?
- State-specific compliance
- No setup fees
- Flat $20–$99/month
Frequently asked